Holiday pie ordering sites

Four Hundred and Twenty Blackbirds

Free shipping costs
Where they deliver: nationwide via Goldbelly
Tuesday through Saturday delivery days

This Brooklyn pie store gained recognition for their Salty Honey pie. Made with honey custard and sea salt flakes, it is a true delicacy. However, the bakery also produces other delectable selections, such as salted caramel apple, bittersweet chocolate pecan, and lemon chess pie. Goldbelly offers pies for next-day delivery in New York City and nationwide shipment. The bakery also has its own cookbook, The Four & Twenty Blackbirds Pie Book, if you’d want to try your hand at pie-making.

Where to shop:

The Salty Honey pie is the hallmark flavor of Four & Twenty Blackbirds, and for good reason. With a flaky pie crust, a honey custard filling, and flakes sea salt, this dessert strikes the ideal mix between salty and sweet. The pie is 9.5 inches in diameter and serves 8 to 10 people.

Few things can compare to a traditional apple pie, but according to the reviews, Four & Twenty’s is better with salted caramel. The 9-inch pie is filled with caramel and topped with sea salt; it feeds 8 to 10 people.

Harry & David

Harry & David

Variable based on order total, beginning at $7.99
Where they ship: throughout the United States
Days of delivery: Varies per destination

Since 1934, Harry and David has been known for bringing fresh food. With such a reputation, it is only natural for the online merchant to use its fresh fruit to create exquisite pies. There are a variety of flavors to pick from, including apple, cherry, and pumpkin. The pies are supplied with two-day express shipping. Depending on the flavor, some options arrive ready to bake, while others are baked and ready to serve.

Where to shop:

This tall, deep-dish pie is a holiday show-stopper and receives amazing reviews. It is produced with actual pumpkin, topped with whipped cream, and sent to your door fully prepared for consumption.

This gorgeous pie allows the fruit to speak for itself. This traditional apple pie is made with only apples and cinnamon in the filling and has a flaky, buttery crust. It arrives ready to bake whenever you have a need for pie.

Little Pie Shoppe

Goldbelly

Free shipping costs
Where they deliver: nationwide via Goldbelly
Tuesday through Saturday delivery days

Since 1985, this New York City bakery has baked pies from scratch. Little Pie Company’s pies may be shipped through Goldbelly in a variety of flavors, including traditional pumpkin and apple, sweet potato, Mississippi mud, and even gluten-free blueberry apple crumb. You can specify your favorite delivery date when ordering pies that are ready to consume upon arrival.

Where to shop:

For many, pumpkin pie is the ideal holiday dessert. This traditional pumpkin pie has a flaky, buttery crust and a pumpkin filling with the perfect amount of spices. The 10-inch pie serves eight to ten people.

Want a gluten-free pie alternative? This key lime pie is lauded by critics. It is made with a graham cracker crust, key lime filling, and fresh lime zest on top. The 10-inch pie serves eight to ten people.

Milk Bar

Milk Bar

Shipping costs range from $15 to $27
Where they ship: throughout the United States
Deliveries are made on weekdays.

Milk Bar may currently be most known for its birthday cake, but the Milk Bar Pie may have an equally devoted fan base. This is the dessert that put Milk Bar on the map of must-try desserts. The oat cookie crust is filled with a buttery, sweet filling with a hint of salt, and it can be shipped directly to your door on the day and time of your choosing for any occasion.

Where to shop:

This is not a conventional pie. It is delicious either chilled or at room temperature and has a cookie-crust foundation with a gooey, sticky filling. The 10-inch pie serves eight to ten people.

The Williams Sonoma Company

The Williams Sonoma Company

Cost of shipping: $12
Where they ship: throughout the United States
Days of delivery: Varies per destination

Did you know that this supplier of kitchen and homewares offers pies? Williams Sonoma offers an extensive variety of tastes, including Buttermilk Pie, Cranberry Mascarpone Pie, and classics such as pumpkin, pecan, and apple. In addition, gluten-free pumpkin and salted caramel apple are available. Just be sure to purchase in advance, as delivery can take up to a week.

Where to shop:

This delectable dessert from Cake Bake Shop in Indiana offers a unique take on the traditional apple pie. It consists of layers of Granny Smith apples with a crumbly topping. The nine-inch pie serves eight to ten people.

The Southern Baked Pie Company in Georgia prepares this 10-inch pie with an all-butter crust. The basic custard filling contains eggs, buttermilk, and vanilla. This tart serves 8 to 10.

Bake Me a Wish

Bake Me A Wish!

Cost of delivery varies by destination
Where they ship: throughout the United States
Monday through Saturday delivery days.

Bake Me a Wish was founded in 2005 with the purpose of delivering birthday cakes across the nation. Now, the New York bakery distributes pies, cheesecakes, cheesecakes, cookies, and brownies. The pies are freshly made and transported overnight for immediate delivery to your table. This is also a terrific way to send a pie as a present, as each pie is shipped in a gift box and you have the option to include a greeting card.

Where to shop:

This light and refreshing dessert is made with a traditional pie crust and a coconut custard filling. The eight-inch pie is topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut and serves six to eight individuals.

This summertime staple is baked with fresh strawberries and rhubarb in a traditional buttery crust. The eight-inch pie serves six to eight people.

Piedaho

Piedaho

Cost of shipping: $19.99
Where they ship: throughout the United States
Wednesday through Friday are the delivery days.

This little family-owned bakery in Idaho produces delicious pies. It drew the attention of Oprah when its pies appeared on her list of favorite items. Each handcrafted pie from Piedaho is filled with local fruit and topped with the most exquisite decorations. Blueberry pear crumble and raspberry nectarine pies are cooked and dispatched with a two-day delivery window. There is also the opportunity to join Piedaho’s Pie Club, which sends unique pies baked with seasonal fruit twice or four times every year.

Where to shop:

This take on apple pie combines sweet and salty flavors and is served in a cinnamon flavored crust with a lovely design. This 10-inch pie feeds eight to ten people.

This pie is made with a vanilla crust filled with fresh pears and blueberries. The crumbly 10-inch pie is covered with oats and brown sugar and feeds eight to ten people.